No experience of any of the above, mostly because I get on so well with the Mitas E-09s that I've had three pairs now and not felt the need to try anything else
.
Cheaper than TKCs, good enough road manners for me to run them all the time. Easily lasted the run down to Spain and back with the HUMM in the middle.
They will still get a bit clogged up if you ride on wet clay...
...but you need a proper enduro tyre to avoid that, which would be horrible on the road. They shed normal mud fine.
TBH though, you need to just bite the bullet and buy a set of something. Everyone has their own taste in tyres.