The post is not tenuous at all, it is what it is.
If you want me to tell you what lid to buy - ok, go buy a Tourx 3 charley. Doesn't matter what lid suited us or which lid we purchased - people would disagree with us as that particular lid is not for them.
That's why you shouldn't reject a lid on other peoples views - try it - like it - buy it. Simples

Ps, no we didn't buy the X3 Charlies

Blimey it's hard to get a point across.